This is where all the AI doomer grifters get off the rails.
“We'll all be left to work as Walmart greeters.”
Here's why that's a LAZY, silly take.
1. Automation Doesn't End Human Ambition. It Redirects Our Attention.
Automation trains us to IGNORE things. Innovation steers us to look at OTHER things.
But NOT ONCE in human history have we stopped choosing what we look at, care about, assign meaning to, tell stories about, build cultures, power hierarchies and/or economies around.
And that's a pretty important detail to leave out of the spreadsheet.
Anything that frees our attention from an activity risks commoditizing that activity.
Remember ATMs?
We don't stand around ATM machines in idle wonder anymore.
We don't obsess over the miracle of pressing a few buttons and watching cash emerge from a wall. That capability became ordinary. Our attention moved elsewhere.
But we didn't stop assigning meaning and worth to things. We didn't stop telling stories. We didn't stop finding problems to solve, creating desires, establishing hierarchies, or building economies.
Maybe some bank tellers obsess over the coming ATM apocalypse. Just like some math teachers feared the scientific calculator, or librarians watched Google arrive and wondered what came next.
But the world did not stop.
Some of those people adapted, some found other work, and the industries affected continued changing.
The world moved on. Tale as old as time.
It's also why the "experts" need more than a STEM background in the age of AI. Because some of these mathletes are so busy calculating the future that they've forgotten the fundamentals of mathematics, language, human behavior, and the very nature of value.
2. The Mathletes Forgot What Math Was For
Yes, language is math. Arguably much more complex math.
We invented mathematical systems to dumb down complexity into something our error-prone human brains could reliably calculate. We reduced complex relationships into symbols, rules, and operations we could understand, communicate, and manipulate with something resembling certainty.
Then we built computers to do it for us.
We are the original broken computers in this equation.
And we invented mathematical language to compensate for that.
Natural language contains relationships, dependencies, context, probabilities, ambiguity, meaning, and the dimensions of human experience that don't conveniently fit into a spreadsheet. That doesn't mean they aren't data or that the underlying relationships aren't mathematical. It means that OUR ability to formalize and calculate them has historically been limited.
Imagine meeting an alien civilization that uses something resembling English to perform calculations involving dimensions and relationships we can't even perceive.
Would that make their language less mathematical, or would it reveal how limited our understanding of mathematics actually is?
Just because we haven't figured out how to formalize a relationship mathematically doesn't mean the relationship isn't mathematical. It may simply mean our mathematics or understanding of it hasn't caught up with reality.
We have a habit of confusing what we can calculate with everything that exists. And it permeates society and culture.
And then we built computers that could execute our simplified mathematical instructions. We created programming languages, specialized technical disciplines, and entire professions around translating human intentions into instructions machines could understand.
3. When The Gatekeepers Become The Doomers
And not to leave our egos and power hunger out of it, we even created a wonderful little intellectual status hierarchy around it.
Learn the specialized language, master the calculations, become one of the initiated, and enjoy feeling superior to people who can't speak your language.
For some, mathematics became a way of feeling intellectually superior without having to talk to people they felt superior to.
We built social and economic classes and power hierarchies around STEM, Elevating technical expertise while willfully leaving other domains of human knowledge behind.
History. Religion. Philosophy. The Arts. Politics. Culture. Real Economics. Human Relationships. The study of patterns in human behavior, civilizations, institutions, and power itself.
These were essential disciplines to understanding the very humanity these technical systems were supposedly being built to serve.
But increasingly, technical sophistication became a substitute for intellectual completeness.
And behind the supposedly neutral language of science, efficiency, progress, and optimization, an ideological worldview gained influence. A secular technocratic vision of humanity in which material explanations are privileged, transcendent moral authority is dismissed, and human beings are increasingly treated as variables to be managed within systems designed by experts.
That's not the absence of ideology. That's an ideology wearing the costume of objectivity. And the people who control the models, define the objectives, establish the measurements, and determine what counts as legitimate knowledge accumulate extraordinary power over everyone else.
We didn't separate religion. The powerful built a new one, handed it calculators, and called it progress.
Then we started to build better computers that could understand NATURAL LANGUAGE.
And suddenly, ordinary people could communicate their intentions directly to machines without needing as many mathletes standing between them.
Imagine that.
The mathletes built machines that could finally understand the rest of us, and now some are panicking because the rest of us don't need them as middlemen as nearly as much. In MBA fancy talk land, they call this disintermediation.
And wouldn't you know it? Some of the same intellectual gatekeepers who once insisted that ONLY THEY could understand these machines now insist that ONLY THEY can understand how dangerous the machines are. The implication is ONLY THEY should be allowed to use them, control them, and control how others use them.
What a convenient way to try to remain indispensable and preserve the power hierarchy.
And there's a darker temptation lurking behind that hierarchy.
When experts begin insisting that ordinary people cannot be trusted to understand or use powerful technologies, the next step is often a demand for greater control over what people are permitted to access, question, build, consume, believe or say. We saw this happen in the COVID era.
At that point, we're no longer merely debating technological safety.
We're debating who gets to exercise power over everyone else's future.
And the recent history offers no shortage of examples of people who justified concentrating power by claiming they alone knew what was best for humanity.
Not every technical expert thinks this way, certainly not consciously. But let's not pretend that ego, narcissism, territoriality, status anxiety, and self-preservation somehow disappear when someone earns a STEM degree.
Humans build identities around what makes them important. When technology threatens the exclusivity of those capabilities, it threatens more than their jobs. It threatens the STORIES they tell themselves about why they matter.
And people will fight like hell to protect those stories.
Which brings us back to economics.
4. The Spreadsheet Is Not The Economy
People create value and assign meaning from their HUMAN experience.
From seashells, beads, and shiny rocks to printed paper, spreadsheets, and pixels, we tell ourselves and others stories about these things in order for them to matter.
We build entire ECONOMIES around them. Not merely math. Not math first. Stories.
Think about that.
We take rocks out of the ground, polish them, attach stories of love and commitment to them, and build industries around the perceived value.
We print symbols on paper and collectively agree they represent wealth.
We assign ownership to pixels, create imaginary work, invent currencies, construct marketplaces, and spend real money on things that don't even exist in the physical world.
We create value systems around things that are visual, persistent, interactive, desirable, scarce, meaningful, or connected to friction points, problems, and aspirations.
And even when we attempt to reduce value to something as seemingly objective as UTILITY, we're still making judgments about what is useful to whom, for what purpose, and why that purpose matters.
UTILITY doesn't escape human judgment. It DEPENDS on it.
We decide what matters, construct systems around those decisions, and then develop mathematics to measure, compare, and optimize what we've already decided is worth pursuing.
And the STORY matters. Including the story that math matters and how.
- The spreadsheet captures a narrow slice of the data.
- The graph illustrates selected relationships.
- The forecast projects a trajectory based on what we've decided to measure.
But what about everything NOT on the spreadsheet?
- The CEO's decision to change the direction of the campaign
- The customers' changing desires
- The cultural movement nobody anticipated
- The conversation that changes someone's mind
- The story that inspires millions of people to pursue something they didn't even know they wanted yesterday
That’s all data too.
And often the story BEHIND the graph is the very thing that changes where the graph goes next.
This is the fundamental problem with treating human economic potential as a closed mathematical equation.
You're assuming the variables, the objectives, and the boundaries of the system remained fixed.
They don't.
5. The Doomer Grift Is Its Own Economic Opportunity
The irony of the moment is that the doomer who monetizes predictions that AI will “doom us all”, or eliminate meaningful economic opportunity are literally demonstrating how human beings create NEW economic opportunities around changing circumstances.
Fear becomes a story that attracts attention, influence, clicks, and thus revenue.
The doomer grift is itself an economic adaptation to technological change.
They're selling a story about how there won't be any more stories worth selling.
This doesn't take away from the danger or pains of technological disruption.
Jobs will disappear, industries will collapse, people will suffer and struggle, and wealth and power can concentrate. Transitions can be brutal, and the people displaced don't often become the people who benefit.
But acknowledging those realities is a LONG way from declaring that humanity is running out of meaningful things to do or ways to contribute.
A world with new things worth doing is not automatically a world where everyone gets paid to do them. But that's a different problem from declaring human economic possibility DEAD.
That's where the doomer argument enters intellectual laziness.
The doomer click-whore era trends towards fear and dystopia because it’s easier to write stories about certain doom than burn the calories imagining new territory and how one might navigate it. There's a high-profit, low-effort, lazy incentive to trend towards dystopian predictions.
Furthermore, even applying some basic logic and analysis you arrive at a different degree of intellectual laziness.
Because for the Walmart greeter prediction to represent humanity's upcoming economic destination, you have to assume something extraordinary, that there are:
- no more desires to discover
- no more experiences to create
- no more relationships to build
- no more cultural movements, ambitions, aspirations, status systems, industries, frontiers, or entirely new categories of value worth pursuing
AND that humans won’t get to choose what has meaning and value anymore.
Really? That's your prediction?
After everything human beings have invented, imagined, built, destroyed, rebuilt, and explored, or dreamed into existence “IT’S OVER” with a popular language prediction machine?
Pack it up, boys. The spreadsheet says civilization has reached its final row. Give me a break.
And even if we somehow solved every problem currently in front of us, we'd get BORED and start inventing new ones.
We'd take to the stars. Full Star Trek mode.
New worlds, new experiences, new problems, new cultures, new economies, new things to explore, discover, fight over, whine about, build, and care about.
The map gets bigger. It ALWAYS gets bigger.
6. The Psychology Of Certain Doom
And this is where the Psychology of Doomerism becomes especially interesting.
Much of it is rooted in lazy, egotistical thinking.
And here's a useful question that doesn't require a doctorate, a supercomputer, or a peer-reviewed study to ask:
CUI BONO? WHO BENEFITS?
Who gains attention by predicting catastrophe?
Who becomes indispensable by convincing everyone else that the future is too dangerous for ordinary people to navigate?
Who accumulates influence by positioning themselves as the exclusive interpreters of technological danger?
Who gains authority when the public is persuaded that only a select group of experts can be trusted to understand, regulate, and control these systems?
And who gets paid to keep telling that story?
Fear doesn't just generate clicks; it can generate STATUS, AUTHORITY, POWER, and REVENUE.
The incentives are sitting right there in plain sight.
Not that all the pessimism is dishonest.
There are serious risks and hazards worth studying and confronting, but there's a difference between identifying danger and declaring the future hopeless because you can't imagine what comes next.
Certain doom is often psychologically easier to embrace than uncertain possibility.
Why?
Because certainty feels like control.
Even a terrible future can be comforting to an ego that would rather be RIGHT about catastrophe than admit it doesn't know what comes next.
There's a kind of intellectual vanity in announcing the end of possibility.
“I have examined the available evidence, calculated the trajectory, and determined that humanity has reached the limits of its usefulness.”
Congratulations. You've confused the limits of your imagination with the limits of civilization.
And you've forgotten a few very important truths:
You are not God.
And you don't know everything.
You don't even know most things.
Neither do I.
Neither does the smartest mathematician, programmer, economist, futurist, or AI researcher on the planet or AI or Super Intelligence (SI) equivalent.
And perhaps that's the deeper problem.
It's not merely that the doomers are making predictions about the future.
It's that they're making those predictions from a fundamentally mistaken understanding of what man IS.
And when you begin with the wrong understanding of man, even the most sophisticated calculations can lead you spectacularly astray.
7. A Compass Pointed At The Wrong North
And here's another fundamental problem with the doomer’s calculations.
They can't orient the compass to TRUE NORTH.
We can build extraordinarily sophisticated machines, feed them mountains of data, give them mathematical precision beyond anything a human being could reliably achieve, and still end up with a fundamentally broken reasoning system.
Why?
Because the machine's calculations are only as useful as the premises, objectives, and understandings of reality that orient them.
Precision is not TRUTH. Calculation is not WISDOM. Intelligence is not DISCERNMENT.
You can calculate your trajectory with extraordinary accuracy and still be headed in entirely the wrong direction.
And this is where the deliberate exclusion of God, creation, and Judeo-Christian understanding of man becomes more than a theological disagreement.
And let's dispense with the fiction that calling a reasoning system SECULAR somehow makes it neutral.
Secularism is not the absence of philosophical premises. It introduces premises of its own.
The decision to exclude God, divine revelation, or transcendent moral authority from the foundations of a reasoning system is itself a philosophical decision.
It doesn't become objectively correct simply because someone labels it the alternatives religious.
And the principle of separating church and state was never a mathematical proof that secular assumptions are true, that religious reasoning is invalid, or that the state possesses the authority to determine ultimate reality.
That's a remarkable amount of philosophical baggage to smuggle into a system under the false label of NEUTRALITY.
You don't get to declare your worldview the default, exclude the competing premises, and then congratulate yourself for eliminating bias. Religious unbelief is still religious.
You've simply embedded your bias at the foundation.
It's a foundational problem of LOGIC.
The very civilization that produced modern science, mathematics, computing, and artificial intelligence developed within a moral and intellectual tradition profoundly shaped by Judeo-Christian beliefs.
Our understanding of human dignity, individual rights, moral responsibility, freedom, justice, the obligations of power, and the very idea that creation possesses an intelligible order didn't materialize out of thin air.
They have ROOTS.
And those roots matter.
These aren’t merely historical influences that can be discarded without consequence. They’re load-bearing premises.
And I'm not arguing that these premises matter merely because Western civilization inherited them. I'm arguing that these describe REALITY, whether modern culture finds them convenient or not.
Yet now we have people attempting to construct the ultimate reasoning machines while DELIBERATELY severing those machines from the very premises that helped produce the civilization building them.
They want the logic without its foundations.
The ethics without their moral authority.
The dignity of man without understanding of what makes a man dignified.
The order without the Author.
They want the fruit of the tree while denying the existence, necessity, or significance of its roots.
And then they wonder why their models struggle to account for meaning, purpose, morality, hope, and the enduring human drive to create.
If a man is merely a biological machine, an economic input, a collection of preferences and computational functions, then, of course, a more capable machine begins to look like his replacement.
But what if your premise about man is WRONG?
What if human beings are more than the sum of their economically useful functions?
What if the desire to explore, create, cultivate, love, sacrifice, discover, and reach beyond ourselves isn't some evolutionary inconvenience to be optimized away?
What if it's part of what we were CREATED to do?
And what if the universe isn't merely an accidental collection of matter waiting to be calculated, but an intelligible creation whose order, beauty, and complexity point towards something greater than ourselves?
You don't get to simply remove these possibilities from the equations, declare the remaining variables exhaustive, and then announce humanity's inevitable obsolescence.
That's not intellectual rigor. That's building an elaborate mathematical model around assumptions you've mistaken for facts.
And the irony is that people doing this often pride themselves on their superior logic.
But logic cannot rescue a false premise.
A machine can calculate a million routes per second. That doesn't mean it knows where it SHOULD go.
It can predict human behavior. That doesn't mean it understands what makes a human life WORTH living.
It can reproduce moral arguments. That doesn't mean it possesses moral discernment.
And if the people building and interpreting these systems cannot distinguish those things, why should we assume their predictions about humanity's future are comprehensive?
Consider the fundamental question of AI alignment.
Who gets to define what humanity is, what humanity is worth, and what humanity is permitted to become?
Aligned to WHAT?
Human preferences? Consensus? Censored consensus? Efficiency? Utility?
Human preferences can be contradictory, self-destructive, immoral, and shortsighted.
Consensus doesn’t establish goodness.
Efficiency doesn’t establish righteousness.
Popularity doesn’t establish truth.
Moral truth is not simply manufactured through consensus or discovered by maximizing utility. It is grounded in a moral order that exists independently of human preference.
You cannot meaningfully answer questions about what is GOOD without first establishing what is TRUE about reality, about man, and about the moral order in which both exist.
And if your starting premise excludes the Creator, denies the spiritual nature of man, and reduces human existence to functions that can be measured, replicated, and optimized, you’ve already corrupted the foundation of your reasoning.
Not merely because the math is wrong. But even more so because the PREMISES are.
A compass pointed at the wrong north doesn't become trustworthy simply because you made it digital.
And a civilization that forgets why man matters shouldn't be surprised when its machines begin treating man as irrelevant.
The doomer thinks the problem is that the machine may become smarter than the man.
The greater danger is that man may become so impressed with the machine's intelligence that he forgets to ask whether either of them knows which direction is TRUE NORTH.
Our models are not reality. Our spreadsheets are not the universe. Our predictions are not prophecies.
And our inability to imagine the next economy doesn't mean the next economy won't exist.
At every major turn of innovation, our perspective expands.
The map gets bigger.
And the people who succeed in these moments do something fundamentally different than the doomers.
The winners of the paradigm shift will do what they have always done:
They will POSITIVELY FRAME the unknown.
They will have FAITH and thus hope for the future.
They will call it OPPORTUNITY.
They hear the echo of an ageless hope that acknowledges both the brokenness of mankind and the promises of his Creator.
And here's another irony worth considering.
For all their mathematical sophistication. Some of these doomers seem incapable of entertaining the possibility of something greater than themselves.
They can model SOME uncertainty, calculate probabilities, and imagine machines more intelligent than humanity, so long as it doesn't mean God, or at least a god they didn’t create.
The doomer can imagine a machine becoming greater than humanity, but cannot entertain the possibility of a Creator greater than the machine, humanity, and the universe itself.
God? Providence? A purpose or intelligence beyond the boundaries of their own perception?
Apparently, those possibilities don't even make it onto the spreadsheet.
They'll entertain the possibility of artificial superintelligence while dismissing the possibility of divine intelligence.
They'll tell us how little humanity understands about the universe, then speak the remarkable certainty about what cannot exist beyond their understanding.
And somehow they don't see the contradiction.
They've confused the limits of what they can measure with the limits of what is possible. Again.
The Western tradition, profoundly shaped by Judeo-Christian thought, offers a different starting point.
Mankind is fallen, imperfect, and limited, but he is also made in the image of God, endowed with reason, imagination, creativity, and a responsibility to cultivate what has been entrusted to him.
We are not God. We do not know everything. We are not promised a life without danger, suffering, or failure.
But neither are we called to surrender to despair simply because we cannot see what lies ahead. That is not blind optimism.
It is HOPE rooted in FAITH, expressed through courage, agency, and action.
8. The Frontier Is Also A Search For Home
And there's something deeper here, something that doesn't fit neatly into the spreadsheet.
Something within man yearns for MORE.
- To be better.
- To be free.
- To discover.
- To create.
- To build something worthwhile.
- To venture beyond the boundaries of what we know and what we are.
And beneath those ambitions is something deeper: the recognition that the world is not as it ought to be, and that our longing for freedom, beauty, meaning, and belonging points towards something beyond our present circumstances.
Something within us reaches towards God, sensing, through the mere existence, order, and beauty of His creation, that there is something greater than ourselves.
The Christian tradition has recognized this longing for centuries.
Eternity written on the human heart.
A restless soul searching for its creator.
The hope of restoration. Of redemption. Of finding our way home.
And perhaps, somewhere deep within that yearning, we're searching for something that we've lost.
A home we've never quite stopped looking for.
We used to call the unknown the FRONTIER and yearned for it.
Uncharted territory where a man could build his own destiny, cultivate something worthwhile, and help build a better world.
But the frontier was never merely an economic opportunity.
It's an expression of man's spiritual longing for something he knows exists but cannot fully see, understand, or possess.
Man explores with hope because something within him recognizes the world, as he experiences it, is not all there is.
He builds because he was made to create.
He seeks because he senses there's something to find.
And he ventures beyond the boundaries of the known world because something deep within him refuses to accept that what he presently sees is all that exists.
The frontier is not just the pursuit of something NEW. In some respects, it's the search for something LOST.
And this is why the doomers continue to doom. Because if man is merely a problem-solving machine, Then a better problem-solving machine appears to make man obsolete.
But if man is a spiritual being whose desire to create, discover, cultivate, and transcend his present circumstances reflects something of his Creator, then the equation changes.
The question is no longer whether AI can perform all the tasks human beings currently perform.
The question becomes whether performing those tasks was ever the full measure of what it means to be human.
And the answer is NO.
We write about pioneers, explorers, adventurers, builders, inventors, and the people who venture beyond the edges of the known world.
We celebrate them because they see something beyond the boundaries of what already exists.
They build new means of travel. New structures. New outposts. New systems. New communities. New ways to communicate, exchange value, organize people, and move civilization forward.
They create stories that attract attention, gather people, mobilize resources, and inspire others to follow. And then they make those stories REAL.
The winners CHOOSE excitement, hope, optimism, curiosity, and exploration.
And they pursue it, knowing they're not guaranteed success, knowing that there are many dangers and perils, and knowing that the unknown is not inherently safe.
But they recognize that danger and opportunity coexist. And it’s because that contrast is what creates the stakes and tension of a story worth pursuing.
The explorer doesn't deny the possibility of failure. He refuses to confuse the possibility of failure with the certainty of defeat.
And that's the distinction.
The doomer looks into the unknown and sees a verdict.
The explorer looks into the unknown and sees uncharted territory.
One declares the story over. The other starts writing the next chapter.
And human civilization has been built over and over again by people willing to write the next chapter.
9. The Map Is Not The Territory
So no, I don't buy the idea that AI means humanity's future is an endless line of unemployed people competing for the last Walmart greeter position.
I don't buy the assumption that automating today's work somehow eliminates tomorrow's ambitions.
And I certainly don't buy the intellectual arrogance of people who mistake their ability to model the known world for an ability to define the limits of the possible world.
The Doomer grift will eventually go out of style, as so many predictions of humanity's final economic irrelevance have before it.
The Luddites, the cowards, the quitters, the threatened gatekeepers, the would-be tyrants who see every technological disruption as another opportunity to consolidate power, and those too lazy or afraid to dream of possibilities that might require getting off the couch will have to find another story to sell.
Or, ironically, they will have to adapt.
Because we’ve never built economies EXCLUSIVELY around what was already necessary, already measurable, already understood, or already possible.
We build them around what we learn to desire, what we choose to value, what we imagine, what we discover, and what we decide is worth pursuing.
And we have NEVER run out of those things.
Automation changes what we no longer need to think about. Innovation changes what we CAN think about.
And human beings decide what matters next. The spreadsheet doesn't get the final word.
Neither do the mathletes.
Neither do the machines.
And neither do the doomers.
The map is not the territory.
And the frontier isn't closed just because you can't see beyond the edge of your spreadsheet.
Share this
Disclaimer
Thinking In Motion
Field Notes represent the authors current stand -thinking while in motion. This is not permanent, polished, Heroik doctrine. Counter claims, better evidence, experience, and argument may change where we land. So, show grace, engage in good faith in the comments, if we're getting it wrong or missing something - say something.
In This Article




0 Comments